Method

Analytical validation of germline small variant detection using long-read HiFi genome sequencing

    • 1 Stanford Medicine;
    • 2 Stanford University;
    • 3 Stanford Medicine, Stanford University
Published April 11, 2025. https://doi.org/10.1101/gr.278836.123
Download PDF Cite Article Permissions Share
cover of Genome Research Vol 36 Issue 6
Current Issue:

Abstract

Long-read sequencing has the capacity to interrogate difficult genomic regions and phase variants; however, short-read sequencing is more commonly implemented for clinical testing. Given the advances in long-read HiFi sequencing chemistry and variant calling, we analytically validated this technology for small variant detection (single nucleotide variants, insertions/deletions; SNVs/indels; <50bp). HiFi genome sequencing was performed on DNA from reference materials and clinical specimen types, and accuracy results were compared to short-read genome sequencing data. HiFi genome sequencing recall and precision across Genome in a Bottle (GIAB)-defined nondifficult and difficult genomic regions (high confidence) for SNVs were >99.9% and >99.7%, respectively, and for indels were >99.8% and >99.1%, respectively. Moreover, HiFi genome sequencing outperformed short-read genome sequencing on overall SNV/indel F1-score accuracy at all paired sequencing depths, which were further stratified across 100 total GIAB-defined genomic regions for a comprehensive evaluation of performance. Of note, HiFi genome sequencing F1-scores for SNVs and indels surpassed 99% at ~15×. and ~25×, respectively. In addition, high confidence small variant concordance across all HiFi genome sequencing reproducibility assessments (two specimens, three independent sequencing datasets) were >99.8% for SNVs and >98.6% for indels, and average high confidence small variant concordance between paired blood, saliva, and swab specimens were all >99.8%. Taken together, these data underscore that long-read HiFi genome sequencing detection of SNVs and indels is very accurate and robust, which supports the implementation of this technology for clinical diagnostic testing.

Loading
Loading
Loading
Back to top