Table 4.

Requirement for Manual Validation of Comparative Results

Concept DIAN /Role node number Present in DIAN and GO DIAN only GO only Reported type I variation Effective number of type I assignments Effective rate of type I variation
Cytoskeletal3.13019160.2940.06
Nucleotide6.5625110.6030.05
Sugar/glycolysis6.703580.8130.07
RNA polymerases5.1.10401.0040.00
RNA processing5.1.249100.3910.04
Transcription factors5.1.3142124980.3400.00**

[i] Type I variation here refers to those assignments made byDIAN but not in the reference ontology implementation system (GO system). Manual validation results show that Type I variation (DIAN-only assignments) cannot simple be treated as Type I error in a strict statistical sense.